The Shop

Fresh from the case, boxed for pickup

Build your bag, then call (919) 759-4741 and we’ll have it waiting at the counter. Everything is baked from scratch each morning — when it’s gone, it’s gone.

Sticky Buns at Mickey's Pastry Shop

Sticky Buns

$4.50

Caramel glaze and pecans, aptly named and impossible to eat neatly.

Cinnamon Buns at Mickey's Pastry Shop

Cinnamon Buns

$4.25

Sweet, raisin-studded, glazed while warm. They rarely survive the morning rush.

Cream Horns

$3.75

A hollow spiral of puffed pastry filled with a cloud of white icing, dusted with powdered sugar.

Cream Puffs

$3.50

Doughnuts filled with a silky cream frosting — started from the same dough as 1946.

Long Johns

$3.50

Like our cream puffs, but shaped long. Made from the shop's ancient starter.

Lemon Squares

$3.25

Constellations of sugar scattered across the top.

Pecan Pie

$4.75

Better than homemade — by the slice, while it lasts.

Layer Cake Slice

$4.50

Not-too-sweet chocolate or vanilla, wrapped in blankets of buttercream.

Ordering a custom cake or feeding a crowd? Call (919) 759-4741 — Melanie’s crew will take care of you.